So, you’ve been binging Pentatonix videos on YouTube, right? You’re totally blown away by those insane a cappella harmonies, and then a little thought pops into your head. Wait, which members of Pentatonix are gay? It’s a fair question, and honestly, a pretty fun one to explore.
Let’s be real—this isn’t a gossip column. It’s more like a friendly “getting to know the band” session. Because in 2024, who you love is just another cool part of the story, especially when you’re as talented as these five.
The Short, Sweet Answer
Here’s the deal: Scott Hoying and Mitch Grassi are both gay. The other three members—Kirstin Maldonado, Kevin Olusola, and Avi Kaplan (who left the group in 2017)—are all straight.
Must Read
That’s it. No drama, no mystery. Just two fabulous, openly gay guys and three equally fabulous straight friends. But let’s dig a little deeper, because their stories are actually super interesting.
Scott Hoying: The Charismatic Baritone
Scott is the guy with the huge smile and the voice that anchors the bass lines. He’s been publicly out since before Pentatonix even won The Sing-Off in 2011. He’s talked openly about his journey, including how his Christian upbringing made it tough at first.
He’s now engaged to doctor and entrepreneur Mark Manio. They’re basically the definition of #couplegoals. Seeing Scott live his best, most authentic life while selling out arenas? That’s pretty inspiring, don’t you think?
Mitch Grassi: The High-Flying Tenor
And then there’s Mitch. This man has a voice that defies gravity—seriously, his whistle register is like a musical unicorn. He’s also been openly gay since the beginning, and he’s become a huge LGBTQ+ icon.
Pentatonix: How the A Capella Group Became (and Stayed) Successful
Mitch is known for his wild fashion, his love of drag culture, and his super-chill vibe. He’s been dating musician Kai Moralez (of the band Bernhoft) for years. Together, Scott and Mitch prove that being gay in the pop world isn’t just okay—it’s a superpower.
Why This Is So Cool (And Not Just a Fact)
Okay, so why does this even matter? Think about it: in a boy band (or any band, really), it’s rare to have two openly queer members who are also best friends. It’s like finding a rainbow-colored diamond in a sea of standard rocks.
Their openness makes their music feel more real. When they sing about love (like in their Christmas songs or originals like “Can’t Sleep Love”), you know it’s coming from a place of genuine joy. It’s not just a performance—it’s their truth.
Representation That Actually Rocks
Think back to when you were a teenager. Wouldn’t it have been amazing to see two guys in a wildly successful group just being themselves, no shame, no hiding? Scott and Mitch are that for a whole generation.
They normalize being gay in a way that’s effortless. They don’t make a huge political statement about it—they just live. And by living openly, they change hearts and minds one beautiful harmony at a time.
Mitch Grassi Gay Rumors Discussed. Is He Married?
A Quick Note on the Straight Members
Let’s not forget Kirstin, Kevin, and Avi. Kirstin is married to Jeremy Lew (a fashion stylist). Kevin is married to his longtime girlfriend, Sophie. Avi is married to his wife, Janae. They’re all supportive allies.
In interviews, they’ve all said that Scott and Mitch’s sexuality is just not a big deal in the group. It’s family. And that’s the healthiest thing ever. They prove that a band can be a safe space for everyone.
The Big Picture: It’s Just Music, Man
At the end of the day, Pentatonix is about voices. Five voices that blend into something magical. Whether Scott is singing to his fiancé or Mitch is wailing about heartbreak—it’s all human experience.
So, are you surprised that two out of five are gay? Maybe not. But isn’t it neat how they’ve turned that fact into just another layer of their coolness? It’s like finding out your favorite coffee shop also has free Wi-Fi—unexpected, but totally welcome.
Who cares if they’re gay, straight, or from Mars? What matters is that they give us goosebumps with every note. And honestly, that’s the only “fact” about Pentatonix that really counts.