Alright, let’s settle in. Grab your coffee—or your iced tea, I don’t judge. We need to talk about Max Scherzer and Cooperstown. Is he a Hall of Famer? Really? Come on, you already know the answer, but let’s chew on it anyway.
The resume is ridiculous. I mean, absurd.
Three Cy Young Awards. Eight All-Star games. A World Series ring with the Nationals in 2019. That’s not just good—that’s “please move aside, I’m building a bronze plaque” territory.
He’s one of only four pitchers in history with 3,000 strikeouts and a winning record over .600. The other names? Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, Roger Clemens. You see what I’m getting at.
Must Read
And his peak? From 2013 to 2019, Scherzer was a monster. I’m talking a 2.71 ERA, 1,800 punchouts, and a WHIP so low it might as well be a whisper. That’s a decade of dominance.
But let’s talk about the crazy stuff.
Remember when he pitched a no-hitter and struck out 17? That was against the Pirates, and it was almost a perfect game. The man missed perfection by a single error on a routine ground ball. He was furious. That’s the vibe.
He threw a second no-hitter the next season. Then a third in 2015. That’s three no-nos. Three. Most pitchers never get one. Scherzer treats them like party tricks.
Max Scherzer Adds Another Milestone to His Hall of Fame Case
And let’s not forget the 20-strikeout game. Against the Tigers, in 2016. He punched out 20 batters over nine innings. That’s tied for the most ever in a nine-inning game. He did it with a blister on his finger. Unreal.
The injury argument? Yeah, whatever.
People bring up, “Oh, he missed time here and there.” So what? He still has over 2,500 innings. He’s a workhorse. The man looks like he’s made of balsa wood and fury, but he keeps going.
His 2021 season with the Dodgers was vintage. He won 10 games, posted a 2.28 ERA, and made everyone remember who’s boss. Age 36. That’s not decline—that’s defiance.
Is Max Scherzer a first ballot Hall of Famer? - ABTC
Even now, in his late 30s, he’s still striking dudes out. His fastball hasn’t lost much zip. His slider still makes batters look like they’re swinging at a ghost.
But what about the Hall of Fame standards? Let’s check the box.
Do you need 300 wins? No. Modern voters care about strikeouts, WAR, and peak dominance. Scherzer’s 60+ bWAR is elite. His 3,300+ strikeouts are top-ten all-time.
Compare him to Mike Mussina. A guy who just got in. Mussina had 270 wins, 2,800 strikeouts, and a 3.68 ERA. Scherzer has better numbers almost across the board. Moose is great, but Scherzer is more.
Even the “character” clause—don’t laugh—is fine. Scherzer is intense, sure. He stares at batters like they owe him money. But he’s respected. He’s a leader. No scandals. Just baseball.
Blue Jays: Max Scherzer gets 'spring training Hall of Famer' buzz vs Twins
Now, the one counterargument.
Some people say, “He played in the juiced-ball era. Strikeouts are up. Everyone looks good.” Okay, fair. But so did Clayton Kershaw. So did Justin Verlander. Context matters, but dominance still counts.
Scherzer’s strikeout rate is historic even for this era. His 12.5 K/9 across his career is higher than Pedro’s. Pedro! That’s not a fluke—that’s a freak.
And he did it without PEDs (as far as we know—zero suspicion). He did it with a delivery that looks like a malfunctioning robot. And a right eye that sometimes looks a different color. Legendary weirdness.
Insider Pours Cold Water on Max Scherzer Returning to Blue Jays
Final verdict? You already knew it.
Max Scherzer is a first-ballot Hall of Famer. No doubt. Not maybe. Not “wait a few years.” First ballot. The man has three Cy Youngs, a ring, a no-hitter hat trick, and more strikeouts than anyone outside the inner circle.
If he retires tomorrow, he’s in. If he pitches until he’s 45, he might chase 4,000 strikeouts. Either way, he’s got a ticket to Cooperstown.
So next time someone asks, “Is Max Scherzer a Hall of Famer?” just do what he does: stare at them like they’re a misguided batter. Then say, “Obviously. Now pass the creamer.”
You’re welcome.